Reading the story made me sad. And afraid. And laugh. But mostly and for reasons I have to investigate I kept thinking how it is almost half my life ago that I was that age. And I think Margo is a sad, lost young woman. I hope she finds herself. Or a way to life to make herself happy.
Okay, I admit it, I got teary-eyed at the end. I did. Despite skipping most of Roran’s storyline. And some stuff. But, yes, I liked it. And I like that he wrapped it up all that well. I’m ready to move on and all is well.
This one started much much better and really had my attention. I also read through it quicker, which translates as me not labouring over it. Also, by now I know which passages to skip. E.g. It would have been enough for me to have Roran sum up his ‚adventures‘ to Eragon over the wedding cake or something. No need to have them in such detail (and yes I know they are there to show character and mood, but honestly, I got it as Roran left Carvahall behind, I didn’t need his Conan-esque behaviour to be shown it all the detail).
But yes, better. More entertaining, but still too slow-paced for me.
I still think that he drew too much on Tolkien’s characters (Beor Mountains, e.g.). It was also too much detail for me and therefore to slow paced. I did skip some paragraphs or only cross-read them. The end was gripping, yes, but to get there took time. Lots of time.
Also, those lovesick boys…*le sigh*…grow up and learn to deal with a no. I also think, that the author misses out on creating some stronger women. Why do the people in Carvahall treat women as grown-up children who need a man to take care of them and who don’t own anything except some cutlery and who, if they don’t own that, lose worth? Not a society I’d want to live in.
Moving on to book three. I shall finish the series.
My edition (not the one I selected but I couldn’t find it) was in tiny print. I’m sure it would have been twice as thick a book if it had been in a regular typing. So it felt like a really slow read. It took me almost 2 weeks and the protagonist reminded me of all the other protagonists in the Dickens‘ novels I have read so far. Which isn’t a bad thing but I wasn’t all that enthusiastic about it. But nonetheless, a good one to read.
I waited impatiently for it and maybe that was the thing, but I wished it had a bit more magic…usually I am left feeling warm and happy and just simply good. And while I still feel some of those feelings, now that I have closed the book, I wish I could have known more about the three women.
I wasn’t all that interested in the protagonist…I couldn’t even tell you his name or if I even read his name, but those women. They are gold. The boy and his troubles reminded me of Coraline and the Other Mother somehow…bad nanny etc. I want to know more about the Ocean…maybe it needed some more words, maybe it’s just me. I’m not saying I didn’t enjoy it or that it isn’t worth a read, I just want more.
At first I was e bit hesitant to start the book, because I work at school and didn’t want to bring work at home. But once I did, I loved it immediately.
I understand Eva, the mom, so much that at times it was uncanny. All my arguments against becoming a mom are in the book (and some other thoughts I’ve had in regards to the USA). All my fears that I’d be just like her (because you simply cannot give it back, the kid I mean), are in the book. So, that was … interesting to say the least.
The writing itself is intelligent and the style fits perfectly. even though I read the book rather fast, I kept wanting to avoid the ending, since I knew what was to come and I didn’t think I was ready to face it but the style helped and it wasn’t clichéd or over the top, I think.
Anyway, I’d recommend the novel without reservations.
There might be spoilers.
So basically it said: obsessive religiousness = bad.
And: Lyra = born liar and temptress and manipulative = female
But in the end it came back to having faith and re-creating religion? Or what? And when did Lyra re-create the Fall and how did Mary tempt her? Honestly, how? To what and when and what was it anyway?
The best part was as they were in the world of the dead but the rest was tedious. So, no, not really my cup of tea. I’m disappointed.
What I don’t like about it is, that Lyra went from protagonist and from being a strong-willed, independent, smart girl to following around a boy, neglecting her mission to find out more about Dust and letting him boss her around (and he did, don’t even start arguing with me).
Why? Is it because she has to fulfill a role that is sexist? The frail woman who had been persuaded and who disobeyed? And why was book 2 narrated in Will’s POV so much? It would have been clear that he also had a part to play if one had stayed in Lyra’s POV. So, I’m not really happy. (Also, the whole religious theme isn’t interesting but that’s just me because I don’t see a necessity in re-writing a story, in this case the Bible. Well…maybe book 3 will be better.)
It took me two attempts to get into the story and on the second it was about half-way through that I sort of was able to immerse myself in it. I did enjoy it but I wasn’t captivated by it. Also, it annoyed me to spot several spelling mistakes in my edition. Not a fan of those.